18.086 | Spring 2006 | Graduate

Mathematical Methods for Engineers II

Study Materials

Papers

Chan, Tony, and Henk A. Van der Vorst. “Approximate and Incomplete Factorizations.”

Benzi, M., G. H. Golub, and J. Liesen. “Numerical Solution of Saddle Point Problems.” Acta Numerica 14 (2005): 1-137. 

MATLAB® Documentation

MATLAB® Technical Documentation

Documentation for MathWorks Products, R2006a

MATLAB® Mathematics Documentation

Other Thoughts

Is there a simple way to count the fill-in in elimination?

Run chol (or lu) and use “nnz” (number of non-zeros)

% Generate discrete Laplacian operator 
A=delsq(numgrid(‘S’,100)); 
% Cholesky factorize 
R=chol(A); 
nnz(R) 
ans = 941289

% As above, but permute rows & columns by approximate minimum degree 
p=symamd(A); 
R=chol(A(p,p)); 
nnz(R) 
ans = 184917

Does min degree just take nodes a row at a time (if it breaks ties correctly)? If that is N^3 - and would sparse backslash do it?

Yes it does, it is a “greedy algorithm.” The approximate one might be a little different, but in principle it does the same thing. Sparse backslash does this automatically. If symmetric, then it uses “symmmd” (symmetric minimum degree), then “chol.” If non-symmetric, “colamd” (column approximate minimum degree), then umfpack.

This is about as fast as possible except for Fast Poisson Solvers?

Well, it is probably as fast as possible for Gaussian elimination. But iterative solvers do better, I think CG with Incomplete Cholesky should be N^(2.5). Then of course fast solvers, FFT-based and multigrid.

Develop a code for Incomplete LU and try it on the 2D matrix for increasing N. You can make it a general code or specialize it to these particular matrices (and decide which entries to keep in the approximate factors L and U). Try on A2D u = random right side. You could use eig to find the spectral radius of the preconditioned matrix B. That matrix is I - inv(P)A2D where P ≈ LU. Of course if P = A2D then B = 0 and convergence in 1 step.

Course Info

Departments
As Taught In
Spring 2006
Level
Learning Resource Types
Lecture Videos
Projects with Examples
Problem Sets with Solutions