24.150J | Fall 2023 | Undergraduate

Liberalism, Toleration, and Freedom of Speech

Calendar

Freedom of Expression: Pro

Session 1: Overview of the class: content; principles of civil discourse

  • Examples of controversial expression, tolerance, and intolerance

Session 2: The case against prior restraint

  • End of class: background on First Amendment cases

Session 3: The First Amendment

Session 4: More on the First Amendment

Session 5: J. S. Mill’s defense of free speech

Session 6: The duty to speak your mind

  • How to write a philosophy paper and a primer on logic

Session 7: Non-government censorship and “cancel culture”

Session 8: Wrap-up discussion of non-government censorship and “cancel culture”

  • Assignment due: First essay

Freedom of Expression: Limits and Opposition

Session 9: Against free expression

  • Comments returned on first essay

Session 10: Defending hate speech restrictions

Session 11: Hate speech restrictions and political legitimacy

  • Assignment due: Revised first essay

Session 12: Hate speech and silencing

Session 13: Hate speech and silencing, cont’d; offensive expression

  • In-class debate prep

Session 14: Offensive expression, cont’d; pornography and harm

Session 15: Pornography and harm, cont’d

Session 16: Pornography and silencing

Session 17: In-class debate                                                                                   

Liberalism, Paternalism, Conservatism

Session 18: New dangers of free speech in the information age

Session 19: Liberalism in 5 minutes; paternalism tentatively defended

Session 20: Anti-paternalism: the knowledge problem

Session 21: Anti-paternalism: autonomy; unintended consequences

  • Assignment due: Second essay

Session 22: Conservatism: against autonomy

Session 23: Liberalism and immigration

Session 24: Conservatism: against gay marriage

Session 25: Religious freedom I. The separation of church and state, pro and con

Session 26: Religious freedom II. Are religious exemptions to general laws justified?

Session 27: Closing discussion

  • Assignment due: Final essay
Learning Resource Types
Readings
Lecture Notes
Written Assignments
Activity Assignments